CASE NAME / ICEBERG
Beneath the surface
of a single decision.
One international delivery. Several contractual, goods and payment chains. And a question that no single document answers in full.
Open the Evidence FileAt first glance, an ordinary delivery.
Equipment, invoices, transport documents and payment. The first snapshot appears sufficiently complete to raise the next question.
- Subject
- International delivery of equipment
- Initial decision
- 18.09.2026 · v1.0
- Jurisdictions
- Russia / UAE / Vietnam
- Payment
- Mixed chain; 15% balance
- Status
- Subject to conditions
Certain facts have been established. The link between all elements has not yet been established.
The party is registered; the goods and route are described in the sources provided.
Sufficiency of authority for the instruction and the complete link between payment and the obligation in the first snapshot.
A transaction has three histories.
Each tells its own story. Matching individual documents does not yet connect them into a single established account.
Who made the commitment, and on what basis?
Parties, authority, contract and terms of performance.
EV-002 · EV-007 · EV-009 · EV-034Which specific goods followed the route?
Invoices, origin, unit number, packaging and carriage.
EV-015 · EV-016 · EV-021 · EV-024 · EV-026 · EV-028Who received the value, and for what?
Instruction, transaction, control over the address and acknowledgement of performance.
EV-035-A · EV-035-D · EV-036A strong document in one chain does not close a gap in another.
Now open the sources.
These are demonstration cards. Final public document extracts have not yet been uploaded; no card depicts an official document.
EV-002Seller registry extractRegistration source · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Registration source, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- Registration status as at the snapshot date.
- Does not support
- The signatory's authority and performance of the delivery.
- Related assertion
- The party exists
- Which gap it closes
- Identification of the legal entity.
- What remains unknown
- Whether the status remained unchanged after the snapshot date.
EV-007Corporate rulesInternal document · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Internal document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The stated decision-making procedure.
- Does not support
- The fact of a specific approval.
- Related assertion
- The payment instruction requires approval
- Which gap it closes
- The rule governing authority.
- What remains unknown
- Whether an exception applies to this instruction.
EV-009Board resolutionCorporate document · Received on 21 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Corporate document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- Approval to the extent stated in the document.
- Does not support
- Performance of each subsequent payment.
- Related assertion
- The instruction was approved
- Which gap it closes
- The authority gap in the first snapshot.
- What remains unknown
- Whether the terms changed after approval.
EV-015UAE → Russia invoiceCommercial document · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Commercial document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The stated parties, goods and amount under this invoice.
- Does not support
- The chain of title and the goods' actual origin.
- Related assertion
- The price for the buyer was agreed
- Which gap it closes
- Terms of sale to the buyer.
- What remains unknown
- How this invoice relates to the preceding sale.
EV-016Vietnam → UAE invoiceCommercial document · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Commercial document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The stated supply and price in the preceding chain.
- Does not support
- That every physical unit is identical across the two invoices.
- Related assertion
- A preceding sale exists
- Which gap it closes
- The existence of a preceding contractual chain.
- What remains unknown
- Whether all items are comparable in configuration and terms.
EV-021Serial numberGoods identifier · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Goods identifier, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The number shown in the source provided.
- Does not support
- What was actually loaded onto the vessel.
- Related assertion
- The unit can be traced
- Which gap it closes
- The starting point for matching the goods.
- What remains unknown
- Whether the unit marking was independently confirmed.
EV-024Form EAVOrigin information · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Origin information, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The fields and origin criterion within the source.
- Does not support
- Actual satisfaction of the criterion and the chain of title.
- Related assertion
- Origin is stated
- Which gap it closes
- A documentary statement of origin.
- What remains unknown
- How the stated information matches the goods.
EV-026Packing listGoods-accompanying document · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Goods-accompanying document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The number and description in the packing list.
- Does not support
- The fact that this specific unit was transported.
- Related assertion
- The unit is included in the package
- Which gap it closes
- The link from the serial number to the package.
- What remains unknown
- Whether the package matches the carrier's record.
EV-028Bill of ladingTransport document · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Transport document, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The consignment and route stated by the carrier.
- Does not support
- The goods' origin and transfer of title.
- Related assertion
- The cargo was handed over for carriage
- Which gap it closes
- The link between the packaging and the stated shipment.
- What remains unknown
- Whether the entire transit chain is separately supported.
EV-029Transhipment recordCarrier source · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Carrier source, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The transit event on the stated route.
- Does not support
- Origin or chain of title.
- Related assertion
- The route passes through Busan
- Which gap it closes
- A gap in the description of the logistics route.
- What remains unknown
- How the event relates to each specific unit.
EV-034Payment addendumContractual source · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Contractual source, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The arrangement agreed by the parties within the text.
- Does not support
- Actual performance and ownership of the address.
- Related assertion
- An alternative payment arrangement is provided for
- Which gap it closes
- The contractual basis for the route.
- What remains unknown
- Whether all conditions for its application were met.
EV-035-ASeller's instructionPayment source · Snapshot as at 18 September
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Payment source, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The performance details stated by the seller.
- Does not support
- A third party's right to accept payment without separate approval.
- Related assertion
- Where to send the balance
- Which gap it closes
- The direction of payment.
- What remains unknown
- Who controls the recipient address.
EV-035-DNetwork transactionTechnical record · After the first snapshot
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Technical record, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The network fact, time, amount and addresses.
- Does not support
- The basis and discharge of a specific obligation.
- Related assertion
- The transfer took place
- Which gap it closes
- Technical confirmation of the transfer of value.
- What remains unknown
- Who owns the address and which invoice the record relates to.
EV-036Seller confirmationCommercial acknowledgement · After payment
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Commercial acknowledgement, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The seller's acknowledgement to the stated extent.
- Does not support
- Any obligations beyond the stated delivery.
- Related assertion
- Performance was credited
- Which gap it closes
- The link between the payment and the creditor's position.
- What remains unknown
- Whether any new objections arose after the acknowledgement date.
EV-037Customs-control eventNew event · After release
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- New event, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The emergence of a new issue and the source's position.
- Does not support
- A breach or a final decision by the authority.
- Related assertion
- The value has been questioned
- Which gap it closes
- Recording the event for re-verification.
- What remains unknown
- How the importer's response will be assessed.
EV-038Importer's response indexSchedule of materials · After the event
SOURCE PREVIEW PENDING
- What it is
- Schedule of materials, presented as a synthetic extract.
- Supports
- The list of arguments and sources submitted.
- Does not support
- Acceptance of those arguments by the authority.
- Related assertion
- The position has been prepared
- Which gap it closes
- The content of the response and its link to earlier snapshots.
- What remains unknown
- The outcome of the review.
A single document sees only part of the transaction.
Select a Form EAV field. The panel on the right shows the boundary of what may be asserted on the basis of that field.
Field extract · not an official form
MASKED · SOURCE PREVIEW PENDINGGoods description
The stated subject matter within Form EAV.
What was actually inside the container. This requires a separate serial → packing → B/L link.
Serial → Packing → B/L → Shipment
- EV-021The number is stated.
- EV-026The number appears in the list; the link to the package requires matching.
- EV-028Carriage of the consignment is described; a single B/L does not establish that it is the same unit.
- Next sourceConfirmation that the unit was actually identified at shipment.
BUSAN / TRANSSHIPMENTTransit ≠ origin. A logistics route ≠ a chain of title.
The difference is visible. Its meaning is not.
The two invoices relate to different links. Reveal the comparison one step at a time.
There is a transaction. But was the obligation discharged?
The 15% balance must pass through the designated settlement agent. The technical confirmation appears compelling—until one asks what exactly it establishes.
network transaction
ESTABLISHES
The existence of the network transaction, its time, amount, addresses and technical confirmation.
DOES NOT ESTABLISH
The legal basis, control over the address, the right to accept performance, the link to the invoice or discharge of a specific obligation.
Six transitions from fact to conclusion
Open any transition: each requires its own basis.
01The transaction exists
EV-035-D records a network transaction. This is a technical fact.
02Address B received the value
The network record shows the destination address; a separate source is required to identify the recipient.
03Address B is controlled by an authorised recipient
Evidence of control over the address and corporate authority is required. A TxID alone contains neither.
04The payment relates to a specific invoice
The contractual addendum and instruction must be matched to the amount, date and invoice.
05The seller acknowledged performance
EV-036 supports the seller's position to the stated extent.
06The obligation may be treated as discharged
A conclusion is possible only within the agreed basis and confirmed acknowledgement; professional assessment is required.
Then life continued.
A decision is recorded as at a date and within a defined scope. A new event changes the state of knowledge, not the earlier document.
Conditions remain open
An initial package is available. The decision on the instruction has not been provided; the payment link is incomplete.
Authority clarified
EV-009 was received on 21 September. The new snapshot closes one gap to the stated extent.
Payment matched
EV-035-D and EV-036 add the network fact and the seller's acknowledgement. The boundaries remain explicit.
Question concerning value
EV-037 records the position on customs value; EV-038 is the index of the importer's response. This calls for re-verification, not an automatic conclusion that a breach occurred.
A new event does not rewrite the earlier decision.
It creates a new verification point.
Why preserve all of this?
EASE ID preserves what was known, what supported it, where the boundary of the conclusion lay and which event requires review.
Sources · facts · links · contradictions · gaps · versions · events
System + methodology + trained user.A rating, transaction guarantee, automatic legal opinion or substitute for a specialist.
Learn more about EASE ID ↗Who can read this file?
Distinguishing a fact, statement, source and link is professional work. The levels reflect responsibility, not merely job title.
- KMS-01International Transaction Coordinator
- KMS-02International Transaction Compliance Officer
- KMS-03Director of International Compliance
How would you read this case?
Five situations with no scores or certificates. After each answer comes an explanation in the language of the Evidence File.
Which source should be requested first?
It seems we have become rather absorbed in the evidence.
After all, you wanted to see the outcome
received by the decision-maker.
One page for the decision. The Evidence File remains beneath it.
DEMONSTRATION SAMPLE
International delivery of equipment
DEAL-2026-0148 · SYNTHETIC
- Counterparty
- Reviewed to the defined extent
- Authority
- Supported within the snapshot
- Origin
- Stated; the actual link requires matching
- Route
- The documentary chain is partially established
- Payment
- The network fact is supported; the legal link has been assessed to the stated extent
- Contradictions
- 2 matters requiring comparison
- Material gap
- 1 open as at the initial decision date
- Review
- Upon new corporate, payment or customs events
The commercial decision is made by the client. This page is not a performance guarantee or authorisation by a competent authority.
EVIDENCE · CLAIMS · BINDINGS · CONTRADICTIONS · GAPS · VERSIONS · EVENTS · REVALIDATION
What matters is not the conclusion.
What matters is what stands behind it.
The decision-maker receives a concise outcome. EASE ID preserves the evidentiary structure that makes that outcome verifiable.
DECISION PASSPORT / DEAL · COUNTERPARTY · MARKET · PROJECT
About the demonstration case
This case is a synthetic literary and analytical construct. Its participants, identifiers, amounts, dates and documents are used for demonstration purposes and do not describe an actual client transaction. The case is fictional. The evidentiary logic is real. EASE does not disclose client materials or information protected by confidentiality obligations.